SIBERIA AND THE SOUTH CHINA SEA
[Note: I am off to Socotra and beyond. Jack Kelly is also away on a well-deserved vacation. In our absence, Joe Katzman will man the HFR ramparts. He is asking TTPers to send him their suggestions for what recent events of note deserve inclusion in the HFR. "Send your suggestions etc. to our new [Half-Full Report email address ] at gmail dot com, the "person" is TTPHFR" - Thanks, and thanks, Joe!]
Here's an interesting question: Do Russians and Chinese exist? Obviously yes in an ordinary sense. But do they possess any individual identity beyond being simply members of their tribal collective?
Human beings seem genetically hard-wired to be tribal. Just about all of us derive at least part of our self-identity via membership in one or more tribes. But most in the West do not submerge their identity into the tribe.
An exception might be a substantial fraction of American Blacks, for whom being "black" overrides everything else. This, of course, is racism, but all forms of racism are merely a variety of tribalism.
For most of us, however - and this includes a great many American Blacks - what we see in the mirror is an individual human being distinct and separate from others. Our participation in the welter of groups and tribes to which we belong is something more of choice than necessity, something that we could withdraw from without feeling at a loss to know who we were.
This is not the case with the great majority of Russians and Chinese. Having little sense of individual empowerment, the average Russian gets a frisson whenever his government pushes other governments and countries around. They want Russia to be a bully. They want other people to be afraid of them because they are Russian.