GUNS DON’T KILL PEOPLE, MORALLY DEFECTIVE CULTURES DO
Earlier this month (9/04) in the Washington Post, Mayor Adrian Fenty and Attorney General Linda Singer of the District of Columbia published an op-ed article defending their determination to appeal a lower court's decision that the District's gun laws, passed in 1976 banning handguns, are unconstitutional.
In the op-ed the Mayor claimed that the laws have "saved lives" as though handguns were some sort of pathogen. Are handguns a pathogen, an agent which causes a morbid condition?
Vermont has the same size population as DC, about 600,000. Yet Vermont has no gun laws. How is it then that Vermont had 2,819 fewer murders over the past 11 years than the District of Columbia? What makes the inhabitants of the District of Columbia 4,860% more likely to die from murder than inhabitants of Vermont? What is the pathogen?
It is not enough to say that the two jurisdictions cannot be compared because Vermont is rural. This seems to imply that rural people are somehow genetically different from people who live in cities, which is absurd. Let me suggest that the pathogen, in all probability, is culture.