HALF-FULL REPORT 02/22/13
What a hornet's nest on the TTP Forum got stirred up by that Congressista's questioning of Social Security in The Traitor in the White House. I guess some clarification is required.
He meant it as a "teachable moment," a thought experiment to demonstrate that just as his conservative audience was determined no matter what to demand their Social Security payments, so is everyone else in America who's receiving some sort of government payout. He thus sees truly cutting government spending as a hopeless task.
He was not questioning Social Security, and was quite interested - as were his two colleagues - in the concept of selling off federal lands (1/3 of the entire US) to pay owed SS benefits when I mentioned it. But his thought experiment backfired, both in his townhall meeting and the TTP Forum because of the visceral emotions surrounding SS.
Here's my perspective. People have been conned by government scammers into thinking that SS taxes are somehow different from income or other taxes. All the money taken by force or extortion by the federalies was earned by those from whom it was taken. Social Security is a government racket, a gigantic Ponzi Scheme. There is no Trust Fund. It does not exist. Your money has been spent.
Further, the purpose of Social Security is to make people dependent on government. Even conservatives, most especially conservatives. I personally look at SS taxes as stolen and gone just like all others. Stealing money is what governments do, and SS money is no different.